MIMR
The Science of Improvement
Improve5 min read

The Hardest Domino Is the First One

One small healthy choice can make the next one easier. The trick is getting the first one to fall.

In 1983, physicist Lorne Whitehead published a short paper about dominoes. He showed that a falling domino can knock over another one about 50% larger than itself.

That sounds modest. But keep going. Each domino topples one a little bigger, which topples one bigger still. Start with a domino the size of a fingernail, and a long enough chain could, in theory, bring down something the size of a building.

The first push barely takes any effort. But without it, nothing moves.

Amelia Earhart put it this way: "The most difficult thing is the decision to act, the rest is merely tenacity."

The power of a small yes

In 1966, Stanford psychologists Jonathan Freedman and Scott Fraser ran an experiment in a California neighborhood.

They asked homeowners whether they'd put a large, ugly sign reading "Drive Carefully" in their front yard. Most said no. Only about 17% agreed.

But a different group of homeowners had been approached a couple of weeks earlier with a much smaller request: put a three-inch sign in your window supporting safe driving. Nearly everyone said yes to that.

When those same people were later asked about the big yard sign, about 76% agreed.

The small yes changed how people saw themselves. I'm the kind of person who cares about this. And once they saw themselves that way, the bigger step felt natural.

Psychologists call it the foot-in-the-door effect. It's the domino principle applied to people: a small first step makes a larger second step easier.

How one choice changes the next

Picture an ordinary day.

You go to bed a little earlier and wake up with more energy. More energy makes a morning walk easier. The walk lifts your mood. A better mood makes the healthy lunch feel less like punishment. You get home less depleted, sleep a little better, and the cycle starts again.

No single step is remarkable. But each one changes the conditions for the next.

Researchers have studied versions of this. In one study of adults with insomnia, a worse night of sleep predicted a shorter workout the next day. Other research has found that sleep loss dampens activity in brain regions involved in weighing choices and makes high-calorie food more appealing.

In other words, last night's sleep may quietly set the difficulty level for today's decisions.

The upward spiral

Psychologist Barbara Fredrickson and her colleagues call this an upward spiral of lifestyle change.

Their idea is that healthy behaviors which feel good create two things. The first is a pull: positive experiences make you more likely to want the behavior again, often without thinking about it. The second is resources: more energy, a better mood, stronger social connections. Those resources make the next healthy choice easier.

The spiral runs in the other direction too. Poor sleep brings fatigue. Fatigue makes exercise less appealing. Less movement affects mood and energy. Suddenly, takeout and the couch look a lot more attractive.

Neither spiral requires a big decision. Both are built from small ones.

Where it gets complicated

The domino image is useful, but real life doesn't grow 50% with every step. One good night of sleep won't trigger a cascade that transforms your health, and one bad night won't doom your week.

Much of the research here is also based on daily tracking, which shows that behaviors tend to move together, but not always which one causes which. In the insomnia study, poor sleep predicted less exercise the next day, but exercise didn't reliably predict better sleep that same night. Some chains run more strongly in one direction than the other.

And chains break. A sick kid, a long shift, or a stressful week can stop a spiral at any step.

That's where Earhart's second half matters. Dominoes fall on their own. People don't. After the first step comes the part she called tenacity: showing up again, especially on the days the chain stalls.

How this shapes MIMR

MIMR is built around both halves of Earhart's sentence.

The decision to act should be easy: a Recovery Room down the hall, no workout clothes, and an account that starts with money in it.

The tenacity comes from seeing progress. We measure before and after, and refresh rewards every 90 days.

Along the way, we'll learn which first dominoes knock over the most others.

Tip the first one. Then keep showing up.

Sources

  1. Whitehead, L. A. (1983). Domino "chain reaction." American Journal of Physics.
  2. Freedman, J. L., & Fraser, S. C. (1966). Compliance without pressure: The foot-in-the-door technique. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology.
  3. Baron, K. G., Reid, K. J., & Zee, P. C. (2013). Exercise to improve sleep in insomnia: Exploration of the bidirectional effects. Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine.
  4. Greer, S. M., Goldstein, A. N., & Walker, M. P. (2013). The impact of sleep deprivation on food desire in the human brain. Nature Communications.
  5. Van Cappellen, P., Rice, E. L., Catalino, L. I., & Fredrickson, B. L. (2018). Positive affective processes underlie positive health behaviour change. Psychology & Health.
  6. Amelia Earhart quote: as listed on the official Amelia Earhart website (ameliaearhart.com).

Measure. Improve. Measure. Reward.

That loop is the whole idea. The Science of Improvement is just us showing our work.

Share this

Read next

Keep exploring